So what did you think of the ladies? - American Idol....

mammag wrote: I liked Carrie. I guess I'm going to be part of the half of America who were really annoyed with Mikalah. She has annoyed me from day one. She needs to start acting like a 16 year old.

I thought Simons comment to Amanda was so inappropriate! You could tell she was embarrassed and didn't know how to respond to that.

So what did you all think?

Boys r us replied: I didn't get to watch it last night

ediep replied: I totally agree mammag, we love Carrie. She was by far the best. I also like Nadia, but not as much as Carrie

TANNER'S MOM replied: Carrie was our choice too, everyone in my house was Carrie..

Did anyone else think the men were better than the women??

Shaykinmom replied: I didn't get to see the whole show but I really likes Carrie

mammag replied:

I did which is sad because I wasn't super thrilled with the guys. It should get a lot better once it really starts live.

Kaitlin'smom replied: did not get to see much of them, Kaitlin had a bad night

jcc64 replied: I liked Nadia alot, liked Aloha, don't know which one Carrie was. Was she the blond with the curly hair? And what was Simon's comment to Amanda- Corey was making too much noise and I couldn't hear it.
I definitely liked the guys better. Totally loved Bo, the music teacher whose name escapes me right now, and Mario. (who I think will win, ultimately)

mammag replied: Something to effect of wanting to be reborn as her microphone. He wouldn't clarify what he meant but it was an awkward moment. Yet he wasn't thrilled with her performance. I forget what he said about that maybe that it was safe or something.

moped replied: I thought the ladies were ok - but not like the guys for sure..........and is Mikalah really 16???????? Really? She did annoy me quite a bit!

Canyou believe that Simon said that about being that girls microphone????

JessC replied: YEAH I agree Carrie was the best... that was the blond one right?

ammommy replied: Is Amanda the Vegas show girl who has been coming on to Simon from day 1? I didn't get to see it because I had a pilates class. Doesn't sound like I missed much, though.

A&A'smommy replied: I didn't get to watch it, I still don't have satelite and I wont until the second

5littleladies replied: Carrie was pretty much the only one I was impressed with. Everyone else seemed pitchy and/or dull. I sure hope they improve!

mammag replied:

No that is Mikalah the 16 yr old who's mom says she is a "good girl", yeah whatever. Amanda is the pretty brunette. Mikalah would have loved it if he had said it to her. She made a comment again about him taking her to her prom.

My2Beauties replied: I don't know about her yet, sometimes she seems annoying but sometimes she seems as if she is doing it as an act and trying to spice things up a bit, she has character I will give her that! I can't believe she is 16 I didn't know that! I like aloha a lot, I have an aunt named Aloha but that isn't why I liked her I think she was good! I didn't get to see all of them unfortunately, I had to give Hanna a bath and she was well "wired" last night!

Kila replied:
Those are my pics for the guys too!

As for the girls, I like Carrie the best. Mikalah is like a train wreck...I can't help but watch her. Don't know what it is.